Playing the Trading Game With Discipline

Trading is the most engaging and challenging activity I do that actually pays me to play. The second most engaging/challenging activity I enjoy is paintball. But a very close third activity I enjoy (and relevant for this post’s purpose) is playing Texas Hold’em Poker.

My cousin and fellow rounder, the one and only “T”, had the usual conversation…discussing poker, trading and what each of us was doing to become better at each one respectively. Of course, the conversation always leads to how similar the attributes needed to do well at one are directly applicable to doing well at the other. And this of course shouldn’t come as any surprise since both activities involve putting money at risk and pitting your skills against the skills of other “players” – with trading this means other traders.

A very good read that hits on many of these similarities (and for the most part I agree with the article) can be found at WallStCheatSheet.com here.

The attributes that I think are the hardest for most people to master is discipline. Once you have the framework of your trading approach (ie. entries, exits, money management, risk capital, etc.) in place, you need to have the discipline to carry out the plan with solid emotional control so that you can succeed and do well at it. Any lapse in judgement or with one’s emotions (read about a recent lapse I had in a previous post, “A Lesson in Sicking With the Plan“) that is allowed to run unchecked will eventually lead to your ruin.

Discipline is required to consistently carry out the following in trading:

  • Mechanical Aspect - Executing the trading plan; maintain level-headed decisions
  • Emotional Aspect - Keeping emotions (fear, greed, euphoria, etc.) under control

Controlling the emotional aspect is the most important because without it you won’t do very well at carrying out the mechanical aspect. Basically, if you’re allowing decisions to be influenced by emotional extremes that everyone faces from time to time, it’s less likely that you’ll be able to make clean level-headed decisions with regards to reading the market or handling your trades. Being able to make rational decisions consistently over time is necessary for any successful trader. Having a lapse which leads to a mistake every now and then is simply being human…but you can’t let it get out of control. Recognize a lapse when it happens, make a conscious effort to prevent it from happening the next time, and learn from the experience.

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post Post to Yahoo Buzz Buzz This Post Post to Delicious Delicious Post to Digg Digg This Post Post to Facebook Facebook Post to MySpace MySpace Post to Ping.fm Ping This Post Post to Reddit Reddit This Post Post to StumbleUpon Stumble This Post

5 Comments

  1. EJ,
    Thanks for your kind reference to my WallStCheatSheet guest post on investing and Texas Holdem Poker.
    I’m not sure if you may be interested, but I thought I would let you (and your readers) know that I have written a new post at my blog about one of the most prominent examples of a successful trader who learnt a great deal from playing poker – Jeff Yass of Susquehanna.
    You can read the post here – http://texasholdeminvesting.com (http://bit.ly/Eh8FN).
    I look forward to any feedback that you may have.
    MF

  2. EJ says:

    Hi MF,

    I definitely enjoyed the article and I’m more than happy to recommend it as well. May the markets, cards and lady luck always be kind to you.

  3. Casey Stubbs says:

    Great Post I just visited the blog after meeting you on twitter Great Work I will return. You know discipline is the key to success at trading and for me I did not achieve this until I had a written plan and a complete system. When I had that it was easy I didn’t have to think or guess I just followed the plan. When you do that trading is really easy.

    For some reason though it took me alot of time and money to learn how to do it the easy way rather than the hard way.

  4. EJ says:

    Hi Casey,

    Thanks and I’m glad you enjoyed the post! I agree that writing down the plan is key – as one should do for any kind of business venture. I think the reason most people don’t do well at trading is because they don’t treat it as a business and instead treat it as more of a gamble or hobby. I’m glad you’re on the right track and definitely feel free to let me know if you ever have any questions that you think I might be able to help out with.

    By the way, a post that I put together that touched on trading as a business was, “90% of You Are Doomed to Fail”. You may or may not have already read it…just throwing out there as something else you might find of interest. The link for it is below:

    http://www.armchairtaikun.com/2009/08/you-are-doomed-to-fail/

  5. [...] on an earlier post regarding discipline, one of the most understated items about being able to trade successfully is [...]

Leave a Comment